What a car costs to keep, not just to buy
The price on the window sticker is only the start of what a car costs you. This guide lists the costs that follow and shows how to estimate each one for your own driving before you choose.
Two cars with similar prices can cost very different amounts to keep. Fuel or charging, tires, maintenance, repairs, registration, the cost to cover the car and the value it loses all add up over the years you own it. Comparing those costs is how you judge what you can really spend.
Right Lane gives no typical figures here, because they depend on your car, your state and your driving. Instead, each section tells you where to find the number and how to work it out. Put the results in one place for each car on your shortlist, and compare the totals over the time you expect to keep it.
Before you buy
- Estimate fuel or charging from your own yearly distance
- Price a set of tires in the car's size
- Read the maintenance schedule for the years you will own it
- Ask for a quote to cover the car before you sign
- Check registration fees and taxes with your state
- Compare resale on older versions of the same model

Fuel or charging
Start with your own yearly distance, divide it by the car's efficiency figure from the label and multiply by what you pay for fuel or electricity. For a plug-in car, split the distance between home charging and any public charging at their different prices. Use the combined figure unless your driving is heavily city or heavily highway.
Check which fuel grade the owner's manual calls for, since premium fuel changes the sum. Cold weather, short trips and heavy loads all raise consumption. A small gap in efficiency adds up when you drive a long way each year.
- Use your own yearly distance, not a typical one
- Use the fuel grade the manual specifies
- Price home and public charging separately
Tires, maintenance and repairs
Tires wear out on every car, and larger wheels, performance tires and heavy electric cars can wear them faster or need pricier replacements. Look up the size the car uses and ask a tire shop what a set costs in that size. Read the maintenance schedule in the owner's manual for the items due during the years you plan to keep the car.
Repairs out of warranty are harder to estimate, which is where the reliability research earns its keep. Ask an independent mechanic what tends to need attention on that model as it ages and what those jobs cost locally. Some cars need dealer-only tools or parts, which can raise the bill.
- Price a set of tires in the car's exact size
- List the scheduled maintenance due while you own it
- Ask a mechanic about common repairs as the model ages
Registration, taxes and the cost to cover it
Registration fees, sales tax and any yearly vehicle taxes vary by state, and sometimes by the car's value, weight or fuel type. Your state motor vehicle office explains how they are worked out. Some states add a yearly fee for electric or hybrid cars in place of the fuel taxes they would otherwise pay.
The cost to cover a car changes with the model, its safety equipment, its repair costs and how often that model is stolen, as well as with you and where you live. Ask for a quote to cover the car before you sign, for each car on your shortlist. Two similar cars can come back with quite different quotes.
- Check fees and taxes with your state motor vehicle office
- Ask for a quote to cover each car before you sign
- Include any yearly fee for electric or hybrid cars
Depreciation and resale
Depreciation is the value a car loses while you own it, and for a new car it is often one of the largest costs of all. It falls fastest early on, which is one reason a nearly new car can make sense. Some models hold their value better than others, and the pattern shows in used listings for older versions of the same model.
To estimate it, compare asking prices for the same model a few model years older with similar mileage and trim. Condition, color, service records and how common the model is all affect resale. If you keep cars a long time, resale matters less than reliability and running costs.
- Compare used listings for older versions of the model
- Keep service records to help resale later
- Weigh resale less if you keep cars a long time
New or used
Buying new
Buying new, the warranty covers many early repairs and maintenance is predictable, but depreciation takes a large share early in ownership. The cost to cover a new car and the sales tax on its price may also be higher. Weigh those against the long, known history you get from being the first owner.
Buying used
Buying used, the price and the value still to lose are usually lower, but repairs and tires may come sooner. Use the inspection report to price any work the car already needs and add it to what you pay. Check how much warranty is left and what the next scheduled services will cost.
Questions
Costs depend on the car, the state, the driver and the timing, so any typical figure would be wrong for many readers. Each section explains where to find your own number instead. Your own estimate is the one that counts.
It can be, depending on what you pay for electricity, how much you charge at home and your local fees. Tires, the cost to cover the car and depreciation can pull the other way. Run the same estimate for each car you are comparing.
Use the length of time you have kept cars before, or how long you expect this one to fit your life. A longer ownership spreads the purchase price but brings more repairs. Run the sums for a shorter and a longer period to see how the choice changes.
General information, not mechanical, legal or tax advice. For one particular car, rely on its paperwork, an independent mechanic and your state motor vehicle office.
